Biofuels Subsidies

Biofuels are not a fledgling industry: last fall the biofuel industry celebrated 30 years of subsidization.  Yet, the industry continues to recieve singificant taxpayer funds.  Friends of the Earth is working to reform these subsidies so that only the most truly sustainable biofuels benefit from subsidization.

There are many ways that biofuels are subsidized.  The Renewable Fuels Standard Mandate creates a market for biofuels, which provides the biofuel industry with significant economic incentive.  But this is not the only way that the biofuel industry benefits.

Biofuels also benefit from tax credits of significant proportions.  Friends of the Earth and EarthTrack analyzed these subsidies and found that the combination of the RFS and the tax credits could provide biofuels will receive $400 billion in subsidies through 2022. Our analysis is found here

Tax credits are specific allotments of money that are given to oil companies when they blend biofuels into their fossil fuels or to the biofuels industry itself.  The tax credits come in many forms.

Tax Credit Name Where Applicable Value
Volumetric Ethanol Excise Tax Credit
To companies that blend ethanol into gasoline, including imported ethanol. $0.45 per gallon
Volumetric Biodiesel Tax Credit
To companies that blend biodiesel into diesel fuel, excluding imported biodiesel. $1.00 per gallon, except fuels co-processed at petroleum refineries
Renewable Biodiesel Tax Credit A parallel tax credit to the Volumetric Biodiesel Tax Credit if the excise tax credit could not be claimed $1.00 per gallon, except fuels co-processed at petroleum refineries
Small Producer Tax Credit To any biofuel producer (ethanol or biodiesel) $0.10 per gallon on the first 15 million gallons per year produced at facilities smaller than 60 million gallons per year
Production Tax Credit for Cellulosic Ethanol To producers of cellulosic ethanol only. $1.01 per gallon total support, but Volumetric Ethanol Excise Tax Credit payments must be netted first

These tax credits are not tied to any sort of environmental performance standards.  This means that even the most ecologically destructive biofuels, such as corn ethanol, are receiving immense funding despite their poor ecological performance.  Meanwhile, precious dollars that could be devoted to truly sustainable energy production and transportation solutions are wasted on these outdated and ecologoically harmful technologies.

 

Our Work on Biofuel Subsidies

Below are links and updates on the different actions that Friends of the Earth has taken to try and prevent environmental damage from the Biofuel Subsidies from Tax Credits.

 

Report: "A Boon to Bad Biofuels" Released

Friends of the Earth released a report in May 2009 that examined the extent to which biofuels are subsidized by the tax credits as well as the Renewable Fuels Standard.  The report found that biofuels received enormous benefits from these policies, particularly when combined.  Between 2008 and 2022, biofuels will have received more than $400 billion in subsidization.  This value could more than double, to $1 trillion, should we continue to increase biofuels production, as President Obama promised in his presidential campaign bid.  Meanwhile, these subsidies are not driving us to sustainable biofuels, and in fact, they support even the most horrendous biofuels, such as corn ethanol. 

"A Boon to Bad Biofuels" Report  | One Page Report Summary | Press Release 

 

Biofuel Industry Celebrates 30 Years of Subsidization

Friends of the Earth recognized the 30th year of subsidization for the biofuels industry in November 2008.  Since the Energy Tax Act of 1978 gave the first subsidy to biofuels, not a single biofuel subsidy has been repealed.  Thirty years later, it may be time for the industry to stand on its own, or at minimum accept performance criteria in order to receive funds.  In 2008, the biofuels industry recieved nearly $8 billion dollars from tax credits.  Friends of the Earth and coalition partners wrote to then-President-Elect as well as congressional leadership calling for the end of unsustainable biofuel subsidies.

Letter to Obama Transition Team and Congressional Leadership

 

Biofuels Tax Credit Extension Attempt

In September 2008, there was an attempt to prematurely extend the Volumetric Ethanol Excise Tax Credit, an enormous subsidy to ethanol.  This tax credit is one of the single largest energy subsidy in existence, yet has no performance criteria, such as environmental safeguards, associated with it.  Friends of the Earth and coalition partners wrote to congresssional leadership asking them not to extend the tax credits at this time or in their current form.

Letter to Congressional Leadership